Thanks for melding your broad interests in culture and music with the challenges of current technology. I don’t entirely understand what Suno does and after reading this will probably never try it. But the blandifcation of current music, and the difficulty of getting out of the Spotify algorithm loop are not just bothersome but, as you point out, deadly to the fostering of real creativity. I try to subvert the Spotify algorithm by searching out weird sub-genres of music or things I normally wouldn’t listen to and favorite them even if I don’t listen to them. Not sure how well it works. Of course, a great way to support creativity on a local level is to support live music of all sorts. Not big arena concerts of established money makers but bar bands, buskers, school bands, open mikes, anyone with the courage to put themselves out there.
Yes! I would highly recommend Liz Pelly's book on how music streaming has so thoroughly undermined the viability of the local scenes we love so much...!
I agree with your concerns, and your loathing of the profit-before-quality bros at Suno, but I would argue that it's several decades too late to lament the potential demise of quality musicianship and well-composed, non-derivative music. The Big Music oligopoly has thoroughly destroyed that already, over the past five decades, to the point all the music analysts I follow are in deep despair over the mindless, nursery-rhyme pap that passes for almost all "contemporary" music today, across almost all genres. Although AI has many, many downsides, I would suggest that the real enemy of high-quality music has always been capitalistic greed. We can close the barn door on AI music tools and their tone-deaf purveyors, but I'm afraid the horses bolted long ago.
Hi Dave, I basically agree with more of this than you might expect.I try to make the point, in the Spotify section, that the ecosystem was already rigged against quality musicianship before AI entered the picture. Liz Pelly's reporting on ghost artist program is devastating on exactly this front. So I don't think we disagree about the diagnosis. Where we might diverge is on the fatalism. The fact that the conditions for serious music-making have been eroding for decades doesn't mean we should shrug at something that accelerates the erosion while letting the executives call it "democratization." Both things can be true: Big Music broke a lot of this, AND AI music tools are making it worse in specific new ways. The barn door metaphor assumes there's nothing left inside worth protecting, but I think there is...thanks for reading
No one will go to the opera or the symphony to listen to Ai generated music anymore than they will stand in front of a piece of Ai generated art in a gallery. It is a tool for creative expression and has its place but that is not in the same space that 100% human created art or music lives. As 90% of human created art or music is slop, perhaps there is a place for Ai creations that are not derivative of human endeavors and also not slop. "Digital art' has long had a place in Film & TV. Where could Ai music fit? The reddit posts you mention are interesting. We need legislation and education, not panic. Good article, got me thinking.
Thanks for melding your broad interests in culture and music with the challenges of current technology. I don’t entirely understand what Suno does and after reading this will probably never try it. But the blandifcation of current music, and the difficulty of getting out of the Spotify algorithm loop are not just bothersome but, as you point out, deadly to the fostering of real creativity. I try to subvert the Spotify algorithm by searching out weird sub-genres of music or things I normally wouldn’t listen to and favorite them even if I don’t listen to them. Not sure how well it works. Of course, a great way to support creativity on a local level is to support live music of all sorts. Not big arena concerts of established money makers but bar bands, buskers, school bands, open mikes, anyone with the courage to put themselves out there.
Yes! I would highly recommend Liz Pelly's book on how music streaming has so thoroughly undermined the viability of the local scenes we love so much...!
I agree with your concerns, and your loathing of the profit-before-quality bros at Suno, but I would argue that it's several decades too late to lament the potential demise of quality musicianship and well-composed, non-derivative music. The Big Music oligopoly has thoroughly destroyed that already, over the past five decades, to the point all the music analysts I follow are in deep despair over the mindless, nursery-rhyme pap that passes for almost all "contemporary" music today, across almost all genres. Although AI has many, many downsides, I would suggest that the real enemy of high-quality music has always been capitalistic greed. We can close the barn door on AI music tools and their tone-deaf purveyors, but I'm afraid the horses bolted long ago.
Hi Dave, I basically agree with more of this than you might expect.I try to make the point, in the Spotify section, that the ecosystem was already rigged against quality musicianship before AI entered the picture. Liz Pelly's reporting on ghost artist program is devastating on exactly this front. So I don't think we disagree about the diagnosis. Where we might diverge is on the fatalism. The fact that the conditions for serious music-making have been eroding for decades doesn't mean we should shrug at something that accelerates the erosion while letting the executives call it "democratization." Both things can be true: Big Music broke a lot of this, AND AI music tools are making it worse in specific new ways. The barn door metaphor assumes there's nothing left inside worth protecting, but I think there is...thanks for reading
No one will go to the opera or the symphony to listen to Ai generated music anymore than they will stand in front of a piece of Ai generated art in a gallery. It is a tool for creative expression and has its place but that is not in the same space that 100% human created art or music lives. As 90% of human created art or music is slop, perhaps there is a place for Ai creations that are not derivative of human endeavors and also not slop. "Digital art' has long had a place in Film & TV. Where could Ai music fit? The reddit posts you mention are interesting. We need legislation and education, not panic. Good article, got me thinking.